TL;DR
Most companies can implement AI agents for accounting in 4 weeks. Start with AP (highest volume, fastest ROI), then expand to AR and reconciliation. Key success factors: start with a pilot, measure everything, and plan for the people side—not just the technology.
You’ve decided AI agents make sense for your accounting team. Now what?
This guide walks through implementation from evaluation to go-live, based on patterns from companies that have done it successfully.
Phase 1: Evaluate (Week 0)
Before signing anything, get clear on what you’re trying to achieve.
Define the Problem
Be specific:
- “We process 500 invoices/month and it takes 3 FTEs”
- “Our DSO is 52 days and should be 35”
- “Month-end close takes 10 days”
Vague problems lead to vague solutions.
Quantify the Opportunity
Calculate current costs:
- AP processing: (invoices/month) x (minutes per invoice) x (hourly cost)
- AR collections: (overdue receivables) x (cost of capital) + (FTE time)
- Reconciliation: (FTE days per month-end) x (daily cost)
This gives you a baseline for ROI calculation.
Assess Readiness
AI agents need:
- Data access - Can you provide invoice images, PO data, receipt data?
- ERP connectivity - Does your ERP have APIs or export capabilities?
- Process documentation - Do you know your current approval rules, GL coding logic, exception handling?
Most companies are more ready than they think. If you have an ERP and email, you can start.
Phase 2: Pilot Design (Week 1)
Don’t try to automate everything at once. Pick a pilot scope:
Option A: Single Process
Automate one process completely:
- AP invoice processing (most common starting point)
- AR collections
- Bank reconciliation
Option B: Single Vendor/Customer
Automate all transactions with one high-volume vendor or customer:
- Proves the concept with real transactions
- Limited blast radius if issues arise
- Clear before/after comparison
Option C: Single Department
Automate accounting for one business unit:
- Operations handles their own AP/AR
- Contained scope with real volume
- Pathway to expansion
Recommendation: Start with AP for a single department or vendor category. It’s high-volume, well-defined, and shows fast ROI.
Define Success Metrics
Before you start, agree on what success looks like:
- Processing time per invoice
- Matching accuracy
- Exception rate
- Human touches required
- Cost per transaction
Measure baseline now so you can prove improvement later.
Phase 3: Setup (Week 2)
Connect Systems
Email Integration
- Connect AP inbox to the AI agent
- Configure forwarding rules if needed
- Test with sample invoices
ERP Integration
- Connect via API (preferred) or file export
- Enable read access: vendors, POs, receipts, GL accounts
- Enable write access: create AP vouchers, update records
- Test with sample transactions
Bank Integration (if doing reconciliation)
- Connect bank feeds
- Historical transaction import
- Payment file integration
Configure Rules
Approval Routing
- Dollar thresholds
- Department routing
- Exception escalation
- Backup approvers
GL Coding
- Default accounts by vendor category
- Override rules for specific items
- Tax handling
Tolerance Settings
- Price variance tolerance (e.g., 2%)
- Quantity variance tolerance (e.g., 5%)
- Vendor-specific adjustments
Set Up Users
- Admin users (configure and monitor)
- Approvers (review and approve)
- Exception handlers (resolve issues)
- View-only users (reporting)
Phase 4: Shadow Mode (Week 3)
This is the crucial step most companies skip.
How It Works
The AI agent processes every transaction, but humans verify before anything is final:
- Agent extracts invoice data → Human confirms
- Agent matches to PO → Human verifies
- Agent codes GL account → Human approves
- Agent routes for approval → Human confirms routing
What You’re Looking For
Accuracy
- Is extraction correct?
- Are matches accurate?
- Is coding appropriate?
Edge Cases
- What does the agent struggle with?
- What exceptions need human rules?
- What training does the team need?
Process Gaps
- Are there steps the agent can’t handle?
- Are there approvals missing?
- Are there integrations needed?
Adjust and Iterate
Shadow mode should run at least one week. Use findings to:
- Refine extraction for your invoice formats
- Add vendor aliases for better matching
- Adjust tolerance thresholds
- Create exception handling workflows
Phase 5: Go Live (Week 4)
Gradual Rollout
Don’t flip a switch on day one. Gradual rollout:
Day 1-2: Auto-process only perfect matches
- All three-way matches that are exact
- No exceptions, no variances
- Human approves everything else
Day 3-5: Add tolerance matches
- Matches within configured tolerances
- Still flag anything unusual
- Monitor accuracy closely
Day 6-10: Expand coverage
- Most matches now auto-processed
- Only true exceptions need human review
- Refine based on feedback
Monitor Closely
First month metrics to track:
- Transactions processed automatically
- Exception rate
- Processing time
- Error rate (things the agent got wrong)
- User feedback
Iterate
No implementation is perfect on day one. Plan for:
- Weekly review of exceptions
- Monthly rule refinements
- Quarterly process optimization
The People Side
Technology is the easy part. People are harder.
Communication
Tell the team what’s happening and why:
- “We’re implementing AI to handle routine work”
- “Your jobs are evolving, not disappearing”
- “You’ll focus on exceptions and relationships”
Training
- How to review agent work
- How to handle exceptions
- How to provide feedback that improves the agent
- How to escalate issues
Role Evolution
Old role: AP Clerk processes 50 invoices/day New role: AP Manager reviews 10 exceptions/day + vendor management
This is a real change. Some people will embrace it; others will struggle. Plan accordingly.
Common Pitfalls
Trying to Automate Everything
Start small. Prove value. Expand.
Skipping Shadow Mode
You’ll miss edge cases that become production problems.
Ignoring Exceptions
If your exception rate is 40%, you haven’t automated—you’ve just created a new manual process.
Not Measuring
If you don’t know your baseline, you can’t prove improvement.
Forgetting the People
Technology implementations fail when people aren’t on board.
Timeline Summary
| Week | Focus | Deliverables |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | Evaluate | Problem definition, ROI model, readiness assessment |
| 1 | Design | Pilot scope, success metrics, project plan |
| 2 | Setup | System connections, rule configuration, user setup |
| 3 | Shadow | Agent running, human verification, refinement |
| 4 | Go-live | Gradual rollout, monitoring, iteration |
Four weeks from decision to value. Most companies see ROI within the first month of production.
Ready to get started? ProcIndex can have your AI accounting team running in weeks, not months. Talk to us